PacLII [Home] [Databases] [WorldLII] [Search] [Copyright] [Privacy] [Disclaimers] [Help] [Feedback]

Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 35 - Digest & Index

You are here:  PacLII >> Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 35 - Digest & Index


Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 35 - Digest & Index

THE FIJI LAW REPORTS

of the cases decided in
THE FIJI COURT OF APPEAL
and in
THE HIGH COURT OF FIJI

1989
VOLUME 35

This Volume may be cited as “35 F.L.R.”

EDITOR:
MICHAEL DISHINGTON SCOTT B.A. (Lond.)
of Gray’s Inn, Judge of the High Court of Fiji

DIGEST AND INDEX

PAGE

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

    Administrative law – ministerial direction – whether ultra vires the Act – Fruit Export and Marketing Act (Cap. 154) Section 7.

    Chang Singh Loong Cop. v. Minister of Primary Industries & Attorney-General

44

 

 

AGENCY

    Agency – Contract for sale of land – whether receipt constitutes sufficient memorandum of agreement – whether alleged lack of memorandum must be specifically pleaded – legal effort of authority to sell – Indemnity Bailment and Guarantee Act (Cap.232) Section 59 (d).

     Rev. Josateki Seru v. Ramesh Pala

25

 

 

APPEAL

    Appeal – “by way of rehearing” – power of the Court of Appeal to take cognisance of facts occurring since the first instance hearing.  Court of Appeal Rules (Cap. 12 – Subs) Rf. 15(1), 22(3), 22(4).

    Vinesh Gir and Ramesh Gir v. Roshni Devi

229

 

 

COMPANIES

    Companies – debenture – moneys payable “on demand” – whether time allowed for payment adequate – effect of appointment of receiver on powers of directors – receiver’s power of sale – whether contractual or statutory – Land Transfer Act (Cap. 130) Sections 77, 78, 79 & 80.

    Gunac (Fiji) Ltd. v. Westpac Banking Corp.; Aryan Building & Marine Supplies v. Westpac Banking Corp & Ors

1

 

 

CONTEMPT OF COURT

    Contempt of Court – alleged breach of Order of Magistrates’ Court – whether alleged defect in the Order a defence.

    Sheela Wati Lal v. Ramendra Mahesh Chaudhary

252

 

 

COURTS

    Courts – setting aside Judgment – powers of registrar – want of jurisdiction – whether remediable by the parties – High Court Rules 1988 Order 13 r 10.

    Somaru Dass v. Moape Naiduki

40

 

 

CRIME: OFFENCES

    Crime:  offences – selling liquor after hours – whether actual delivery of the liquor a necessary ingredient of the offence – Liquor Act (Cap.192) Sections 48, 49 (3), 50 and 54 (1).

    Bhabauti Prasad v. The State

73

 

 

CRIME: PROCEDURE

    Crime:  procedure – principles governing application of the proviso to Section 319 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap. 21).

    Bhagauti Prasad v. The State

73

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Crime: procedure – unlawful sexual intercourse – plea of guilty – whether prosecution absolved from need to prove age of victim – Penal Code (Cap.17) Section 155 (1) – Criminal Procedure Cope (Cap.21) Section 206.

    Hazrat Ali (State) Proceedings

217

 

 

CROWN (STATE) PROCEEDINGS

    Crown (State) Proceedings – whether the Attorney-General is liable for the Sheriff’s failure to execute a writ of possession – Crown (State) Proceedings Act (Cap.24) Section 3(5).

    Vijay Parmanandam v. The Attorney-General

259

 

 

CUSTOMARY LAW

    Customary law – entitlement to chiefly title – judicial review of decision of the Native Lands Commission – Native Lands Act (Cap.133) Section 17 (1).

    Bulou Eta Kacalaini Vosailagi v. NLC & Ors

116

 

 

ECCLESIASTICAL LAW

    Ecclesiastical law – constitution of the Methodist Church of Fiji – whether suspension of constitution lawful.

    Rev. Josatekil Fifi Koroi v. Rev. Ratu Isireli Caucau & Ors.

58

 

 

ESTATE

    Estate – Fiji National Provident Fund – failure by testate deceased to nominate – how sum standing to deceased’s credit to be distributed – Fiji National Provident Fund Act (Cap.219) Section 32, 34, 35 and 43.

    In the Matter of Mohammed Hassan

107

 

 

EVIDENCE

    Evidence : criminal – the onus of proving that a parking meter is not of the approved type or is not in working order lies on ka defendant – Traffic Act (Cap. 176) Section 79.

    SCC v. Nitya Mudaliar

140

 

 

EVIDENCE:  CRIMINAL

    Evidence: criminal – sexual assault – recent complaint – corroboration – distressed condition of complainant.

    Saha Deo v. The State

236

 

 

FAMILY LAW   
   Family law – application for ancillary relief – whether a separate action subject to the law of limitation – Matrimonial Causes Act (Cap. 51) Part XIII.

    Colin Ernest Philp v. Anna Francisca Philp & Sione Tupouniua

17

 

 

FAMILY LAW

    Family law – whether “cohabitation” and “residing” are equivalent – when maintenance order becomes unenforceable or ceases to have effect – Maintenance and Affiliation Act (Cap. 52) Section 6.

    Saras Wati v. Mahendra Deo Singh

170

 

 

FOREIGN JUDGMENTS

    Foreign Judgments – reciprocal enforcement –whether judgment of Supreme Court of Hong Kong registrable – whether Fiji’s departure from the Commonwealth relevant – application to set aside – principles applicable – Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act (Cap.40) Sections 3, 6, 9.

    HBZ Finance Ltd. v. Shantilal Brothers

207

 

 

FOREIGN JUDGMENTS

    Foreign Judgments – reciprocal enforcement – whether District Court of New South Wales a “superior Court”.  Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal enforcement Act (Cap.40) Section3.

    In the Matter of Clement James Brown

203

 

 

INCOME TAX

    Income Tax – subdivision and sale of devised land by non-resident – whether profit taxable – Income Tax Act (Cap. 201) Section 11(e).

    CIR v. Edward Charles Woodward

48

 

 

INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES

    Interpretation of Statutes – whether an earlier edition of an Act is repealed by a subsequent edition of the same Act.

    Riaz Hussain & Rochene Hussain v. The State

174

 

 

JUDICIAL REVIEW

    Judicial Review – whether there exists a right to renew an application for judicial review following the dismissal of a similar application on the same grounds – High Court Rules 1988 Order 53.

    In the Matter Haroon Ali Shah

102

 

 

LAND

    Land – adverse possession – vesting order – whether occupation by the State prevents accumulation of prescription period – whether temporary occupation by the State precludes claim based on adverse possession. – Land Transfer Act (Cap.131) Section 78 and 90.

    Bechani Golay v. North End Property Development Ltd.

89

 

 

LAND

    Land – indefeasibility of title – easements – artificial drainage – whether unencumbered owner of the land entitled to obstruct – Land Transfer Act (Cap. 131) Section 39.

    Prince Vyas Lakshman & Anr v. The Trustees of Sanatan Dharam Stri Sabha & Ors

164

 

 

LAND

    Land – Crown (State) land – mortgage – whether an agreement to mortgage crown land requires consent – whether a mortgage is created upon agreement or upon registration – Crown (State) Lands Act (Cap.132) Section 13 – Land Transfer Act (Cap.131) Section 5, 37.

    Suruj Kumari v. Rewa Development Ltd.

36

 

 

LAND

    Land – purchase of land by non-residents – whether agreement to purchase subsequently approved by the Minister enforceable – Land Sales Act (Cap. 137) Section 6.

    Thomas D. Hunter & Anr. v. Francis Joseph Apgar & Anr.

180

 

 

LAND

    Land – transmission by death of agricultural land – application for summons for possession – effect of application to Agricultural Tribunal – Land Transfer Act (Cap.131) Sections 169, 172; Agricultural Landlord and Tenant Act (Cap. 270) Section 4 (1).

    Vinesh Gir and RameshGir v. Roshni Devi

229

 

 

MONEYLENDERS

    Moneylenders – memorandum of interest charged – whether receipts promissory notes – whether transactions within the Moneylenders Act (Cap.234) Section 16 (i); Bills of Exchanges Act (Cap. 227) Sections 88 and 95.

    Sampat v. Sohan Singh

245

 

 

PRACTICE (Civil)

    Practice (Civil) – compromise of actions – whether the Court has jurisdiction to vary the terms of the settlement.

    Michelle Apartments Ltd v. Jayanti Lal Pala & Ors

194

 

 

PRACTICE (Civil)

    Practice (Civil) – defamation action – mareva injunction – quantum of sum secured.

    Newspapers of Fiji Ltd. v. James Ah Koy & Lavinia Ah Koy

82

 

 

PRACTICE (Civil)

    Practice (Civil) – discovery of documents – public interest immunity – how to be claimed – when documents to be inspected by the Court.

    PSC v. Manunivavalagi D. Korovulavula

22

 

 

PRACTICE (Civil)

    Practice (Civil) – Judgment by consent – application to set aside whether application may be made in action settle or whether fresh action must be commenced – application for stay – whether stay warranted RHC O 47 r1.

    State Transport Ltd. v. The Housing Authority

13

 

 

PRACTICE (Civil)

    Practice (Civil) – compromise of actions – approval of settlement in favour of person under disability – function of the Court – procedure to be followed – High Court Rules 1988 Order 80 rule 8.

    Suresh Chand v. Hermant Kumar 

    Anjilini Lata Sen v. Yakub Kadir 

    Shailesh Narayan v. Rajendra Ram

154

 

 

PRACTICE (Civil)

    Practice (Civil) – limitations on operation of the “slip rule” – High Court Rules 1988 Order 20 r 10.

    Suresh Sushil Chandra Charan & Anr v. SCC & Anr

152

 

 

PUBLIC SERVICE

    Public Service – Prisons Service – whether termination of employment a discharge – whether termination unlawful – Prisons Act (Cap.86) Section 12 & 15.

    Josefa Vuetaki v. The Commissioner of Prison & The Attorney-General

98

 

 

PUBLIC SERVICE

    Public Service – pensions – length of pension able service – relevance of conscription for war service – Pensions Act (1958) Cap 59 (1967 Edn.).

    Ram Narayan Cheta v. The Attorney-General

197

 

 

SENTENCE

    Sentence – unlawful sexual intercourse – mitigatory factors – Penal Code (Cap.17) Section 155 (1).

    Emosi Banuve v. The State

249

 

 

TRADE UNIONS

    Trade Unions – Judicial review to quash registration of new Union – Registrar’s failure to hold due enquiry – Trade Unions Act (cap. 96) Section 13 (1) (2).

    Seafarers Union of Fiji v. The Registrar of Trade Unions & Fiji Foreign-Going Seamen’s Union

134

 

 

TRAFFIC

    Traffic – third party policy of insurance – whether statutory liability of insurer a defence to criminal proceedings for driving without being covered  by a third party policy – Traffic Act (Cap.176) Section 23 (1) – Motor Vehicles (Third Party Insurance) Act Cap. 177, Section 4(1) & (2).

    Riaz Hussain & Rochene Hussain v. The State

174

 

 

TRAFFIC

    Traffic – parking meters – whether subject to Weights and Measures Act, 1979 – effect of presumptions of regularity contained in the Traffic Act (Cap.176) Section 79.

    SCC v. Nitya Mudaliar

140

 

 

WORDS & PHRASES

    Words and phrases – “sells or supplies” – Liquor Act (Cap.192) Section 49 (3) – Sale of Goods Act (Cap.230).

    Bhagauti Prasad v. The State

73

 

 

WORDS & PHRASES

    Words and phrases – whether “cohabiting” and “residing with” are equivalent.

    Saras Wati v. Mahendra Deo Singh

170


PacLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback
URL: http://www.paclii.org/fj/indices/cases/FLR_Vol35_Index.html