PacLII [Home] [Databases] [WorldLII] [Search] [Copyright] [Privacy] [Disclaimers] [Help] [Feedback]

Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 38 - Digest & Index

You are here:  PacLII >> Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 38 - Digest & Index


Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 38 - Digest & Index

THE FIJI LAW REPORTS

of the cases decided in
THE SUPREME COURT OF FIJI
in
THE FIJI COURT OF APPEAL
and in
THE HIGH COURT OF FIJI

1992
VOLUME 38

This Volume may be cited as “38 FLR”

EDITOR:
MICHAEL DISHINGTON SCOTT B.A. (Lond.)
of Gray’s Inn, Judge of the High Court of Fiji

 

INDEX AND DIGEST

PAGE

ADMIRALTY

    Admiralty – action in rem – warrant for arrest of a vessel – claim in respect of its construction – whether gratuitous promise has cause of action – how affected by prior debenture.

    ASD Marine Proprietary Ltd & Anr v. Pacific Navigation Ltd & Ors

4

 

 

BILLS OF EXCHANGE

    Bill of Exchange – non negotiable cheque – whether stolen cheque passes good title – whether regularly indorsed – whether third party liable to drawer – Bills of Exchange Act (Cap.227) Sections 3, 29, 32, 76 and 81.

    CIR v. Ko Chau Cheun

138

 

 

BILLS OF SALE

    Bill of Sale – motor vehicle – priority of bills – effect of failure to register – Bills of Sale Act (Cap.225) Sections 3, 7, 12.

    BNZ v. Ian Riki Ripikoi & Anr

1

 

 

BILLS OF SALE

    Bill of Sale – early repayment of loan – whether harsh and unconscionable to require debtor to pay interest on the loan for the entire contractual loan period – Bills of Sale Act (Cap.225).

    Niranjans Autoport Ltd v. Titus Adit Narayan

12

 

 

CONSTITUTION

    Constitution – whether applicant entitled to be registered on the Fijian Roll of Voters – whether the applicant’s enrolment on the Vola ni Kawa Bula a decision relating to customary law – Constitution (1990) Sections 100 (4), 113, 156 (a); Fijian Affairs Act (Cap 120); Interpretation Act (Cap.7) Section 2 (7) (a).

    James Michael Ah Koy v. The Registration Officer

75

 

 

CONSTITUTION

    Constitution – Bill of Rights – elections – whether size of deposit violates right of freedom of association – Electoral (Conduct of Elections) Regulations 1992 Regn. 15 (10); Constitution 1990 Section 14 (2).

    Sakeasi Butadroka v. Attorney-General & Electoral Commission

145

 

 

CONTRACT

    Contract – counsel’s fees – whether agreed in advance – Legal Practitioners Act (Cap 154) Sections 15 & 18.

    Jagat Lal & Ors v. Sohan Singh

183

 

 

CONTRACT

    Contract – building contract – effect of engineers certificate – value of unsupported allegation of fraud.

    Venkat Sami Naidu v. D. Chand Brothers

64

 

 

CRIME:  OFFENCE

    Crime – Offence – procuring abortion – whether use of instruments “unlawful” – Penal Code (Cap.17) Sections 172, 221 & 234.

    DPP v. Sefanaia Bilovucu Tabua

192

 

 

CRIME:  OFFENCES

    Crime – Offences – whether incitement to violence an ingredient of the offence of sedition – Penal Code (Cap.17) Sections 65 and 66.

    DPP v. Afasio Mua & Others

226

 

 

CRIME:  OFFENCES

    Crime – Offences – permitting a person to drive without being the holder of a driving licence – whether an offence of strict liability – Traffic Act (Cap.176) Section 23 (1).

    Michael Rafoi v. The State

203

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Crime – Procedure – whether discharged assessors may be replaced mid – trial – whether failure to comply with assessor provisions of the Code renders the trial a nullity – Criminal Procedure Code (Cap.21) Section 285.

    Ashok Kumar & Ors v. The State

58

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Crime – Procedure – trial within a trial whether contrary to law to hold in the presence of the assessors – whether failure strictly to comply with requirements for contents of judgment a curable defect – whether trial Judge should have rejected the unanimous opinion of the assessors.

    Jay Mati v. The State; The State v. Narayan Singh

120

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Crime – Procedure – when to commit non electable offences for trial in the High Court – Criminal Procedure Code (Cap.21) Section 220.

    Mohammed Khalil v. The State

198

 

 

DAMAGES

    Damages – interim award against the state – procedure governing – State Proceedings Act (Cap.24) Sections 15 (1) (a), 20 (1) & 20 (3) – High Court Rules 1988 Order 29 rr 9.10 & 11.

    Consolidated Realtors Limited v. Attorney-General

206

 

 

ELECTIONS

    Elections – Constitution – Bill of Rights – whether size of deposit violates right of freedom of association – Electoral (Conduct of Elections) Regulations 1992 Regn. 15 (10).

    Sakeasi Butadroka v. Attorney-General & Electoral Commission

145

 

 

EMPLOYMENT

    Employment – recruitment policy – whether discriminatory – whether susceptible to declaratory judgment – High Court Rules 1988 Order 25 r.5.

    Air Pacific Employees Association v. Air Pacific Ltd

46

 

 

EMPLOYMENT

    Employment – contract of service – hotel house band – whether hotel liable to pay Provident Fund contributions – Fiji National Provident Fund Act (Cap.219).

    FNPF v. Fiji Mocambo Ltd

117

 

 

EMPLOYMENT

    Employment – Roko Tui Ra – whether Permanent Secretary for Fijian Affairs may accept the resignation of a Roko – Fijian Affairs Act – (Cap 120) Sections 4, 12 & 14.

    Kolinio Buiboto Matalau v. The Fijian Affairs Board

177

 

 

EVIDENCE

    Evidence: Criminal – corroboration – circumstantial evidence – how far capable of amounting to – whether evidence of one offence capable of corroborating another.

    Sakiusa Mocevakaca & Ors v. The State

102

 

 

EXTRADITION

    Extradition – whether the High Court has jurisdiction to entertain an application for bail following an order for committal made by the Magistrates Court – whether extradition is a “criminal cause or matter” to which the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap.21) applies – Extradition Act (Cap.23).

    Helmut Paul Kasper Rutten v. The State

162

 

 

EXTRADITION

    Extradition – whether there is in existence a valid extradition treaty between the U.S.A. and Fiji – whether extradition proceedings must comply with the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap.21) – whether test of dual criminality satisfied – whether alleged offence of a political character.

    Re:  Helmut Kasper Paul Rutten

164

 

 

FAMILY LAW

    Family Law – divorce proceedings – ancillary relief – intervention by the Attorney-General – when available – Matrimonial Causes Act (Cap.51) Sections 76, 77 & 81.

    Elvis Mahendra v. Satya Wati & Tabsu Nadan Gounder

90

 

 

FOREIGN JUDGMENT

    Foreign Judgment – registration of in Fiji – relevance of Exchange Control Act (Cap.211) – Foreign Judgment (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act (Cap.40).

    First Mortgage Ltd. v. Romanella Pty Ltd & Ors

71

 

 

INSURANCE

    Insurance – rental car – whether the hirer of a rental car drives the car as the rental company’s servant or agent – Motor Vehicles (Third Party) Insurance Act. (Cap.177).

    Michael Bans v. Jan’s Rental Cars (Fiji) Limited

158

 

 

INSURANCE

    Insurance – whether assured had insurable interest – whether misrepresentations material to insurer’s risk – whether want of approval by Director of Lands relevant – State Lands Act (Cap.132) Section 12.

    Jadu Nandan v. Queensland Insurance Co. Ltd.

220

 

 

JUDICIAL REVIEW

    Judicial Review – whether available to contest an award of the Arbitration Tribunal – Trade Disputes Act (Cap.97) Section 6 (1).

    The State v. Arbitration Tribunal ex parte Maikali Naikawakawavesi

234

 

 

JUDICIAL REVIEW

    Judicial Review – whether certiorari available to quash a decision of the disciplinary committee of a sporting body.

    The State v. M.S. Sahu Khan & Anr ex parte Iosevo Visaboto

83

 

 

JUDICIAL REVIEW

    Judicial Review – renewal of road service licence – applicant’s legitimate expectation – procedural fairness – Traffic Act (Cap. 176).

    The State v. T.C.B. ex parte Yanuca Tours Ltd

33

 

 

JUDICIAL REVIEW

    Judicial Review – a decision to disallow a person from knowingly taking advantage of a mistake does not give rise either to an estoppel or to judicial review.

    Western Wreckers Ltd. v. The Comptroller of Customs & Excise

96

 

 

LAND

    Crown (State) Lands – protected lease – whether Director’s consent must be obtained before commencing legal proceedings – Crown (State) Lands Act (Cap.130) Section 13(1).

    ANZ Banking Group Ltd v. Devi Chand

61

 

 

LAND

    Land – drainage easements – whether Plaintiff’s land so encumbered – Land Transfer Act (Cap.131) Section 39(1).

    Prince Vyas Lakshman & Veena Devi Lakshman v. The Trustees of Sanatan Dharam & Ors

42

 

 

LAND

    Land – State land – foreshore – whether island foreshores privately owned – State (Crown) Lands Act (Cap 130) Section 2, 20, 23 (1), 23 (2) & 33.

    Tokyo Corp. v. Mago Island Estate Ltd. & James Borron

25

 

 

LANDLORD & TENANT

    Landlord and Tenant – statutory control of rentals – whether pre-existing agreements subject to new Regulations – whether Regulations ultra vires the Act – Counter Inflation Act (Cap.73) Sections 12 & 13.

    Labasa Town Council v. Morris Hedstrom Limited

153

 

 

LOCAL GOVERNMENT

    Local Government – Bus Station By-laws – meaning of term “visit” – Lautoka Bus Station Taxi and Lorry Stand By-laws – Cap 125 subs.

    Pacific Transport Ltd v. Lautoka City Council

112

 

 

PRACTICE (CIVIL)

    Practice (Civil) – damages – interim award against the state – procedure governing – State Proceedings Act (Cap.24) Sections 15 (1) (a), 20 (1) & 20 (3) – High Court Rules 1988 Order 29 rr.9, 10 & 11.

    Consolidated Realtors Limited v. Attorney-General

206

 

 

PRACTICE: CIVIL

    Practice (Civil) – effect of irregular service of a writ on subsequent application for summary judgment – RHC 10 r 1 (1) and O 14 r 1 (1).

    Carpenters Fiji Ltd v. Augusto Tassinari

67

 

 

PRACTICE: CIVIL

    Practice (Civil) – application for summary judgment – whether lack of affidavit in answer fatal to the Defendant – High Court Rules 1988 Order 14.

    Chandra Lachmaiya Naidu & Anr v. Carpenters Fiji Limited

215

 

 

PRACTICE:  CIVIL

    Practice (Civil) – application for declaratory relief – challenging exercise by a public official of a power derived from statute – whether Originating Summons a permissible procedure.

    Rama Gopal v. Attorney-General

211

 

 

SENTENCE

    Sentence – non – reconcilable offences – duty of the Court to take into account de facto reconciliation when imposing sentence – Criminal Procedure Code (Cap.21) Section 163.

    Ratu Peni Baleidraiba Kevetibau v. The State

110

 

 

SENTENCE

    Crime – Sentence - manslaughter – death following illegal abortion.

    Saras Devi v. The State

94

 

 

TRADE MARKS

    Trade Marks – whether proposed trade mark deceptive, contrary to morality and offensive – Trade Marks Act (Cap.240) Ss 8, 10.

    Japan Tobacco Inc. v. Administrator General

20


PacLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback
URL: http://www.paclii.org/fj/indices/cases/FLR_Vol38_Index.html