PacLII [Home] [Databases] [WorldLII] [Search] [Copyright] [Privacy] [Disclaimers] [Help] [Feedback]

Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 41 - Digest & Index

You are here:  PacLII >> Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 41 - Digest & Index


Fiji Islands - FLR Volume 41 - Digest & Index

THE FIJI LAW REPORTS

of the cases decided in
THE SUPREME COURT OF FIJI
in
THE FIJI COURT OF APPEAL
and in
THE HIGH COURT OF FIJI

1995
VOLUME 41

This Volume may be cited as “41 FLR”

EDITOR:
MICHAEL DISHINGTON SCOTT B.A. (Lond.)
Of Gray’s Inn, Judge of the High Court of Fiji

PRICE:  $27.50
(V.A.T.  Incl.)

DIGEST AND INDEX

PAGE

CONSTITUTION

    Fiji Citizenship – whether lost – whether resumed – Constitution 1990 Chapter III.

    The State v. The Registration Officer, Tailevu Fijian Provincial Constituency ex parte Samuela Matawalu

204

 

 

CONTRACT

    Nadi Airport Duty Free Concession – nature of exclusive rights – power of Civil Aviation Authority to grant – whether subject to Fair Trading Decree 1992.

    The Civil Aviation Authority of Fiji v. Motibhai & Co. Ltd

31

 

 

CONTRACT

    Deed of guarantee-extent of duty of care of a creditor  - whether creditor has any duty to exercise a power of sale.

   Fiji Development Bank v. Inoke Moto & Others

236

 

 

COURTS

    University – whether a claim by a member of a university relating to its internal affairs is justiciable in the Courts. 

    Dr Patrick Muma v. The University of theSouth Pacific & Ors

101

 

 

COURTS

    Magistrates Courts – whether Magistrates Courts have a summary jurisdiction akin to that enjoyed by the High Court under RHC O14.

    Mahesh Chand & Ravindra Chand v. Carpenters Fiji Ltd

155

 

 

CRIME:  DEFENCES

    Defilement – defence of reasonable belief – Penal Code Section 156 (1) proviso.

    Director of Public Prosecutions v. Seremaia Amato & Others

18

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Procedure to be followed after guilty plea – CPC Section 206 procedure to be followed when alternative count charges.

    Director of Public Prosecutions v. Seremaia Amato & Others

18

 

 

CRIME: PROCEDURE

    Proceeding to sentence without having formally entered a conviction – whether sentence a nullity – Criminal Procedure Code (Cap.21) Section 206 (2).

    Epeli Delai v. The State

168

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Crime procedure how far there is scope for Judicial Review of interlocutory rulings in criminal proceedings in the Magistrates Courts.

    Re. Geoffrey Miles Granger Johnson

181

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

      Committal for sentence – matters which must be taken into account – Criminals Procedure Code (Cap 21) Section 222

    Jonati  Cama & Isoa Ratuva v. The State

121

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Committal for trial – Accused unrepresented – no preliminary enquiry held – committal a nullity – Criminal Procedure Code (Cap21) Section 255 proviso.

    Kitione Gaunavinaka v. The State

126

 

 

CRIME:   PROCEDURE

    Whether failure to supply an interpreter amounts to an abuse of the process of the Court sufficient to warrant staying the Proceedings.

    The State v. Chew Pui Qi

177

 

 

CRIME:   PROCEDURE

    Prosecution’s duty of disclosure of witness statements to the defence – DPP’s guidelines approved subject to further observations.

    The State v. Jamuna Prasad

223

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Committal by Magistrates Court for sentence – meaning of “character d antecedents” – Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 21) Section 222 (1).

    Timoci Momotu v. The State

50

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Defilement – proper approach to sentencing where offence committed by adolescents in the course a mutual display of affection.

    Livinai Namami  v.  The State

152

 

 

CRIME:  PROCEDURE

    Larcency by servant improper deferral of sentence to allow repayment – need for consistency in sentencing sentence reduced.

    Mukesh Chand Pratap v. The State

142

 

 

ELECTIONS

    Successful candidate disqualified – whether runner up to be declared returned or whether new election to be held.

    Josevata Kamikamica v. The Returning Officer & Ors

254

 

 

FAMILY

    Appeal against grant of decree nisi of divorce – standard of proof of adultery claim for ancillary relief – whether matrimonial jurisdiction of Magistrates limited by their civil jurisdiction – Magistrates Courts Act (Cap 14) Section 16 – Matrimonial Causes Act (Cap.51) Section 11 (1) (b).

    Aisha Bi & Aruf Dean v. Mohammed Fida Hussain

85

 

 

FAMILY

    Family – maintenance of illegitimate children principles governing aware – Maintenance & Affiliation Act (Cap 52) Section 18 92).

    Sarifan Vi v. Saibaj Khan

145

 

 

INCOME TAX

 

    Liability of non resident enterprise in respect of profits derived in Fiji – whether having a “permanent establishment” in Fiji – whether activities of a “preparatory or auxiliary character” – Fiji/UK double taxation convention Cap.201 Subs s69.

    The Commissioner of Inland Revenue v. Commonwealth Development Corporation

108

 

 

JUDICIAL REVIEW

    An interim stay order may be granted in cases of especial urgency even before leave to move for judicial review has been obtained.  Rules of the High Court 1988 Order 53.

    The State v. Transport Control Board ex parte Shore Buses Ltd

267

 

 

LANDLORD & TENANT

    Agricultural tenancy – whether S44 of the Agricultural Landlord and Tenant Act (Cap 270) allows parties to contract out of the provisions of Section 37 of the Act.

    Venkatamma v. Bryan Charles Ferrier Watson

258

 

 

LOCAL GOVERNMENT

    Whether native land within municipal boundaries rateable – Native Land Trust Board’s duty of payment – Native Land Trust Act (Cap 134) Section 11 – Local Government Act (Cap 125) Sections 2 and 60.

    Labasa Town Council v. Miriama & NLTB

217

 

 

MORTGAGE

    Mortgagee’s rights and remedies how far only exercisable in a particular order – Property Law Act (Cap.130) Section 75.

     National Bank of Fiji v. Abdul Kadeer Hussein

12

 

 

NATIVE LAND

    Whether native land within municipal boundaries rateable – native Land Trust Board’s duty of payment-Native Land Trust Act (Cap.134) Section 11 – Local Government Act (Cap125) Sections 2 and 60.

    Labasa Town Council v. Miriama & NLTB

217

 

 

NATIVE LAND

    Permission of native owners to lease – claim that proper procedures not followed – whether native owner may sue for infringement of personal rights – Native Land Trust Act (Cap 134) Section 23.

    Ratu Malakai Waqatabu v. NLTB & Another

25

 

 

NEGLIGENCE

    Multiple injuries – assessment of damages.

    Nacanieli Moce v. Neori Racule & Durga Prasad

187

 

 

NEGLIGENCE

    Personal injuries – damages – claim for special damages and interest.

    Tacirua Transport company Limited v. Virend Chand

44

 

 

PRACTICE: (CIVIL)

    Application for leave to appeal against interlocutory order – principles upon which direction to be exercised – Court of Appeal Act (Cap 12) Section 12 (2) (f).

    Abdul Kadeer Kuddus Hussein v. National Bank of Fiji

130

 

 

PRACTICE: (CIVIL)

    Want of prosecution – inordinate and inexcusable delay – prejudice to the holding of a fair trial – status of findings of fact and exercise of discretion.

    Merit Timber Products Ltd v. NLTB

247

 

 

PRACTICE:  (CIVIL)

    Mortgage action – requirements of High Court Rules Order 88

    National Bank of Fiji v. Abdul Kadeer Hussein

12

 

 

PRACTICE (CIVIL)

    Whether relator actions are part of the law of Fiji

    Ratu Mosese Banuve Tuisawau v. Suva City Council & The Attorney-General

70

 

 

PRACTICE (CIVIL)

    Judicial Review – power to grant leave – whether refusal of leave by High Court final or interlocutory.

    Suresh Charan v. S.M. Shah & Others

65

 

 

PUBLIC SERVICE

    Disciplinary proceedings – power to dismiss and procedures to be followed – Police Service Commission Regulations Regn. 22, 23, 24 and 26.

    State v. Police Service Commission ex parte Beniamino Naiveli

197

 

 

PUBLIC SERVICE

    Disciplinary proceedings – circumstances in which PSC must enquire into the truth of denied charges – PSC (Constitution) Regulations 1990 Regn. 41 (6).

    The State v. Public Service Commission ex parte Michael Raman

77

 

 

PUBLIC SERVICE

    Public Service – disciplinary proceedings – whether immoral conducts not adversely affecting the performance of duties amounts to improper conduct – Public Service Commission (Constitution) Regulations 1990 Regn. 36 (t).

    State v. PSC ex parte Oveti Laladidi

159

 

 

TORTS

    Malicious prosecution – false imprisonment – liability of the State for torts committed by servant or agent – judicial immunity.

    Litiwai Setevano v. The Attorney-General

135

 

 

TRADE DISPUTES

    Secret ballot – whether validly conducted – whether employer or Registrar of Trade Unions has power to decide location – Trade Union Regulations (Amendment) Regulations 1991 Regn. 10(1).

    State v. Minister for Labour & Industrial Relations

1

 

 

TRADE UNIONS

    Whether Acting Registrar may be appointed retrospectively – Trade Unions Act (Cap.96) Sections 3 & 4.

    State v. Minister for Labour & Industrial Relations

1


PacLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback
URL: http://www.paclii.org/fj/indices/cases/FLR_Vol41_Index.html